Why the concept of a Mandate in politics is discredited: Insights from Political Science

Why do winning candidates claim a mandate even though political scientists generally discredit the mandate theory of elections?

Winning candidates want to justify their policy proposals by claiming that the public supports them.

The concept of a mandate in politics and elections refers to a candidate’s perceived authority to govern, based on their victory in an election. Winning candidates often claim to have a mandate from the people, which they argue empowers them to enact their policy proposals with greater authority and legitimacy. However, political scientists generally discredit the mandate theory of elections due to several reasons:

1. Limited Voter Information: Most voters do not have a comprehensive understanding of the issues and policy proposals of the candidates they vote for. Thus, a candidate’s victory might not necessarily reflect the preferences of the entire voting population accurately.

2. Contingent Nature of Electoral Victory: Given that election outcomes are contingent on multiple factors beyond the candidate’s control, such as campaigns, fundraising efforts, or opposition weakness, the win cannot always be linked to a specific policy proposal.

3. Multiple and Often Conflicting Mandates: Winning candidates may be elected based on several reasons, ranging from the fact that they represent the constituency’s cultural values, to their views on a particular hot-button issue. Therefore, they often have multiple, and sometimes conflicting, mandates, making it challenging to determine which specific mandate they are expected to deliver.

In conclusion, while winning candidates may claim a mandate based on their election victory, the idea of a mandate as a source of governing authority is generally discredited by political scientists. As such, political leaders need to be cautious about their claims of having a mandate and be more inclusive in their governance and policymaking, representing the interests of all citizens, and not only the ones who voted for them.

More Answers: