Shortcomings of Pluralism in Society: Group Fragmentation and Elitism

2 Problems with Pluralism

Conflicts with our moral judgements in some cases must keep your promisesConflicts are between two perfect duties

Pluralism is a concept generally associated with the existence of diverse and conflicting views, opinions, beliefs, and values within a society. The idea behind pluralism is to promote tolerance, respect, and acceptance for different perspectives, which can lead to a more open and democratic society. However, pluralism has some shortcomings that can challenge its principles and effectiveness.

1. Group fragmentation: Pluralism can lead to fragmentation and division within a society, contributing to the formation of identity politics that promote the interests and agendas of specific groups. This can create a situation where individuals feel more loyalty to their particular group than to the broader society. Such fragmentation can lead to social conflict, inequality, and even violence, especially when groups feel their interests have been ignored or discriminated against.

2. Elitism: Pluralism can also be criticized as being elitist, as it implies that individuals should have the freedom to express their different views and beliefs in a society, but there is a tendency for some groups or individuals to have more resources to promote their ideas than others. Therefore, pluralism can favor the interests of those who have more power, wealth, or influence over those who lack such resources. In this way, pluralism may not provide equal opportunities for all and can lead to the exclusion of some voices and perspectives.

In conclusion, while pluralism is an important ideal that can foster diversity and openness in a society, it has some drawbacks, including group fragmentation and elitism, that need to be addressed to ensure that it effectively promotes the ideals of equality, justice, and democracy.

More Answers: